“ Coolest coffee shop with such a neat history! Inside there is a plaque with info on what Pegasus started out as years ago. I loved this little addition. Inside feels like a cozy cottage! Pegasus is located right next to a seating area that overlooks the water. Probably the best place to sip a hot chocolate on a cold morning. Great coffee and delicious pastries too. The service is great. Friendly team who were all very helpful. ”

“ Came here mid to late afternoon and had the best eggnog latte of my life. Honestly, it was probably the best latte I've ever had, full stop. Staff are super friendly. My boyfriend got a peppermint mocha which was also so good but came out way cooler than my drink which was just a little weird. Love that they serve dude's donuts as my boyfriend has celiac. Ambiance is like the average coffee shop, cute and rustic. I loved the option to send a post card from their store. ”

“ This is a lovely little coffee house with both pleasant indoor and outdoor patio space to enjoy your treat and beverage. If you sit on the patio in the summer, you can enjoy the tops of the boats and hopping birds. The inside has an electric fireplace, but it could be a little more fire-like. It's a little faded. The baked goods are Macrina Bakery and they are delicious. I especially love the croissants, pain au chocolate, and raspberry oat bar. My husband loves the morning glory muffin. ”

“ Pegasus Coffee House on Bainbridge Island is a cozy gem, perfect for fall days. The warm, inviting ambiance is ideal for escaping the chill, with rustic decor and charming nooks for a relaxed afternoon. Located near the ferry terminal, it's easy to pop in while exploring the area. I've tried a few seasonal drinks here: the pumpkin pie latte was tasty both last year and this year, with a perfect autumn vibe. The apple cider chai, though, was just okay. This year, I also tried the pumpkin cold foam cold brew, but they were out of the foam and used regular creamer instead--not quite the same effect but still enjoyable. The service was very nice and prompt. One interesting touch is a photo on the wall that showcases Japanese residents from Bainbridge's past, a nod to the island's history. Overall, Pegasus offers a unique, cozy experience with solid fall drink options. ”

“ Truly one of the most beautiful little coffee shops hidden waterside on bainbridge island. The service was friendly, there was live music and the drinks got out to us pretty quickly. We were also able to find seating on a Friday afternoon. Espresso was nice and strong and the drinks were not too sweet at all. Very pleasant. I also ordered the Samoas Girl Scout cookie doughnut and it was just okay. A little on the dryer side, but still edible. Pleasant experience and would do it again. ”

“ After seeing Pegasus Coffee House on every single Bainbridge Island itinerary on social media, my family couldn't miss this spot while visiting the island. I ordered a 12oz iced mocha with oat milk and enjoyed how creamy and smooth it tasted. There was a good balance between the taste of the coffee and the sweet flavour of the chocolate. The baristas were super sweet and helpful, and our coffee came out within five minutes of us ordering. When my mom let a barista know about there not being toilet paper in the bathroom, she immediately went to change it. We appreciated the welcoming and speedy service. The atmosphere of the coffee shop was also very cozy. The lights and décor are cute and I think it's nice that they also have board games to play. We easily found a table in the mostly empty cafe, though it was dirty and we had to wipe it down ourselves. I also loved that they had free postcards on the counter! I wrote one to my little sister and I can't wait to bring her here for a sister reading coffee date. Obsessed with this place and the staff and will definitely have to come back. ”

“ We had a truly wonderful visit to Pegasus on Bainbridge island. The shop itself is beautiful, kind of made me feel like we jumped into the Shire hehe. The place was busy, so you know it's going to be good. Line out the door type situation. I ordered an iced mocha with oat milk, which was great. They have a little bar next to the water station with cinnamon, nutmeg, etc. you can add to the drinks if you wish. Next time with more time I'd love to spend time inside the shop, read, etc. The patio was also very pretty for summer days! ”